Solitude and Silence in Cottonwood Canyon

Author standing in Cottonwood Canyon, Sierra Nevada in background

“The desert empties you…it is not a place wherein you can decide how you want to grow and change, but is a place that you undergo, expose yourself to, and have the courage to face. The idea is not so much that you do things there, but that things happen to you while there—silent, unseen, transforming things. The desert purifies you, almost against your will, through God’s efforts. In the desert, what really occurs is a cosmic confrontation between God and the devil; though this happens within and through you. Your job is only to have the courage to be there. The idea is that God does the work, providing you have the courage to show up.”
Father Ron Rolheiser, OMI

“Nothing resembles the language of God as much as does silence.”
Meister Eckhard.

The wind is blowing a horrific cloud of polluted dust thousands of feet into the sky above the ancient Owens Lake east of the Sierra Nevada. I am driving north on Highway 395 past Olancha, at the southern tip of the lake, on the second day of my traditional Lenten desert retreat. I can see snow falling over the Sierra Nevada as clouds darken the mountain slopes down to the valley floor.

Cottonwood Canyon looking back toward horrific dust storm over Owens Lake

I am heading north toward Cottonwood Canyon, a place I have driven by dozens of times, but never visited. As I cross the highway bridge over Cottonwood Creek, the dry wash is filled with scars from previous flash floods. On the right side of the road, beside Owens Lake, I see a band of aspen, willow and cottonwood trees on the edge of an ancient shoreline. That is where the Owens Valley Paiute village of Sunga’va was located for 6,000 years and recently excavated by UC Davis. This was a verdant place, when the lake was high, with abundant duck, deer and antelope. A mile south of that village are the ruins of two charcoal kilns, built by Col. Sherman. He also constructed a long wooden flume that went up into the Sierra and denuded the slopes of the pinyon pine, a key protein source for the Indians. Sherman made charcoal that was loaded on to a boat at a landing, also near the Indian village site. Small steamboats carried the charcoal across the lake in the 1880s to Swansea, when it was used to smelt silver ore.

The wind is brutally strong, rocking my 2002 Oldsmobile Bravada. I see a small sign, “Cottonwood Road,” turn left off Highway 395 and drive toward the power station at the foot of the mountains. The dirt road crosses the Los Angeles Aqueduct that has drained the Sierra snowmelt for almost one hundred yards, directing the precious water toward booming Los Angeles.

The dirt road continues left toward Cottonwood Canyon and alternates between graded gravel and paved asphalt for the next five miles. I guess the erosion of the road is further evidence of the violent storms that drain out of this canyon. The road climbs, twists and turns, and a wondrous sight unfolds before me, making it difficult to focus on driving the road. Huge granite walls loom higher and higher in beautiful and strange formations of red and orange. I am entering into the heart of the Sierra mountains. Tree topped crests covered in snow rise before me. Once I have entered the shelter of the canyon, the loud, rushing desert windstorm has been blocked out. Silence.

Clusters of green oak trees are more numerous now and there is the sound of rushing water from the snowmelt thousands of feet above me. The sun is warm, the air still and not a single human can be seen. Suddenly a bobcat rushes past me. I am a stranger in this canyon and even the birds are silent. Deeper and deeper I drive into the twisting canyon. There is an old clapboard green building, maybe a Forest Service residence. But no one is here. This place was crowded with campers and fishermen during the fishing season, a place to retreat from the intense summer heat in the valley below. I park at the end of the road, which is the trailhead for the Cottonwood Trail, an ancient Indian trade route over the Sierra Nevada and now a popular summer hiking trail.

I am at rest. My busy mind finds solace here in solitude in this canyon. A spirit of gratitude to God flows through my heart.

I remember that there are also ghosts here: echoes of the presence of Paiute families, who lived and flourished in the canyon for ten-thousand years. There is also the echo of gunfire; a last stand of a Paiute chief and his warriors at the mouth of this canyon, who defended themselves from white settles in the 1860s.

On March 19, 1863, Lieut. Doughty and twenty soldiers from Fort Independence with twenty citizens followed the trail of thirty-seven Paiutes moving south of Manzanar.

“The trail was followed… a point two miles or so north of Cottonwood Creek, when a bullet through a man’s hat gave warning of the nearness of the foe. The Indians were found strongly posted in a ravine about five miles south of the head of Owens Lake. They were dislodged, and a running fight ensued, the whole action taking about four hours before they made a last stand on the lakeshore, not far from the mouth of Cottonwood Creek. ….Lieutenant Doughty was dismounted by accidentally shooting his own horse through the head. Corporal McKenna received a load of buckshot in his foot from another accidental shot and an Indian arrow in his chest. When he fell, a Paiute known as Chief Butcherknife ran up to finish him, but was slain. More casualties to the whites resulted from bad handling of their own weapons than from those of the foe.”

“With sixteen dead on the field, the remaining Indians sought refuge in the waters of the lake. A strong wind blowing from the east interfered with their escape by swimming, and one after another was killed in the light of a full moon rising over the eastern mountains.” The Story of Inyo, by W. A. Chalfant. 1933.

During the night, one surviving Paiute escaped westward into Cottonwood Canyon.

I am remembering that battle and other struggles of the native people as I walk past a grove of oak trees. Somewhere near these trees is where native ceremonies such as weddings and naming rituals still take place.

I am walking around boulders and old willow and cottonwood trees, nearing the rushing waters of Cottonwood Creek. I find a flat rock to sit in the warm sunshine. The air is calm. Tree leaves rustle and flutter. Water flows and trumbles over boulders in hypnotic rhythm that captivates me. My consciousness dissolves into this scene, mind empties, and breath slows. God is very close, embracing me with love and peace. I gaze into the water and remember these words from the Tao Te Ching:

Cottonwood Creek flowing to the low places

“The Supreme good is like water,
which nourishes all things without trying to.
It is content with the low places the people disdain.
Thus it is like the Tao.”
Chapter 8. Translation by Stephen Mitchell

I imagine someone else sitting on that flat rock over there beneath the towering sycamore tree. His long hair and beard flow over a rumpled, sackcloth robe. He is also focused on the water flowing from the mountain above into the low, receptive basins. He is Lao Tzu:

Said to be a mythical figure, historians tell us that Lao Tzu lived in the 6th century BCE. The great Zhou dynasty had disintegrated in the Warring States period. Do you remember the great suffering, deaths and political chaos following the breakup of Yugoslavia? On a mega level, this is what was happening in China: wholesale slaughter of populations and burning of cities. Power was in the hands of ruthless warlords. How could the pieces of China be put back together? Two answers came forth. Confucius returned to the core values of early Zhou feudalism. The other answer came from Lao Tzu and Taoism: a withdrawal to nature and simplicity.

I imagine Lao Tzu sitting on the rock next to me beside Cottonwood Creek. We gaze together at the water flowing from the mountain high above. Water is fluid and can penetrate the finest cavities. It flows to the low, receptive places, breaking down the hardest rock. The Tao is like water, nourishing all creatures without controlling them.

Lao Tzu looked to the patterns and flow in creation, giving him intuitive insight about the nature of Ultimate Reality (the Tao) and how we should best live.

“There is a being, wonderful, perfect.
It existed before heaven and earth.
How quiet it is!
How spiritual it is!
It stands alone and it does not change.
It moves around and around,
But does not on this account suffer.
All life comes from it.
It wraps everything with its love as in a garment.
And yet it claims no honor, for it does not demand to be Lord.
I do not know its name, and so I call it Tao, the Way.
And I rejoice in its power.”

Spiritual Poetry: Lao Tzu Meditation from YouTube:

When I reflect on the Tao with my world religions students at Saddleback College, I usually get blank faces. Up to that point, we had studied Hindu deities and Buddhist bodhisattvas, with vivid personalities. The Western mind struggles with the mystery of the Tao. As if to counter our Western need for categories and descriptions of the Holy, Lao Tzu short circuits our linear thinking in his teachings. As we read the Tao Te Ching, he gives us paradoxes to guide into mystery.

Lao Tzu is teaching us that silence and solitude in Nature is the best experience for communion with the Holy, the Tao. “Standing in front of it, you will not discover its beginning; standing behind it, you will not discover its end. Only standing within its ongoing creative action will you feel the enfolding embrace of the Tao.”

Although Moses received the name of God on Mount Sinai, the Jewish people eventually have avoided use of the holy name of God. Jewish mystic Martin Buber wrote that when we speak of God, we mean “the essential mystery, the unknowable, and the paradox of paradoxes.”

Thomas Aquinas wrote a lot about the nature of God, giving us the classic Five Proofs of the Existence of God. But as he grew older, he gave into the Mystery, saying: “we cannot contemplate how God is, but only how God is not. This is the ultimate in human knowledge of God: to know that we do not know him.” Toward the end of his life, he is said to have confessed, “All that I have hitherto written seems to me nothing but straw.”

I have had the same experience. As I grow in friendship with God, I have many times when I have confessed: I have been a priest for 42 years and I feel like I know nothing, I understand nothing. What I do know are my foundation experiences of the love and goodness of God.

“The master leads
By emptying people’s minds
And filling their cores,
By weakening their ambition
And toughening their resolves.
He helps people lose everything
They know, everything they desire,
And creates confusion
In those who think that they know.”
Chapter 3, translation by Stephen Mitchell.

You will recognize some similarities to the teachings of Lao Tzu and Zen Buddhism. When Buddhism came to China, it blended with Taoism to create Zen.

I remember that howling, jostling winds still blowing on Highway 395. The air is still and the quiet serene in this protective womb of canyon cliffs. Lao Tzu guides us to quieting our minds, practicing “no mind,” as the constant storm of voices and sounds assault us on the outside. In silent meditation, on this rock, I go to that deep place where God’s love flows. I cannot put words on those encounters, even though I try to write about this later in my journal. What I do want to remember is the intuitive encounter with Holy Mystery.

Ron Rolheiser encourages us to make these retreats into silence and solitude:
“There is a huge silence undergirding us and inside of us that is trying to draw us into itself. To enter that silence is to enter the reality of God and the reality of our real communion with each other. For this reason, all great religious traditions and all great spiritual writers emphasize the need for silence at times in our lives… Thomas Merton put is, there is a hidden wholeness at the heart of things, and that hidden wholeness can only be discovered if we get to the deepest level of things. And the language we need to get there is the language of silence—the language of God and the language of intimacy.” “The Language of Silence,” Ron Rolheiser’s blog of January 28, 2007.

If you practice Centering Prayer, meditation with Lao Tzu will sound familiar. As you sit in solitude and quiet in the morning, before the start of a busy day, you follow the instruction of Thomas Keating:
“We close our eyes to what is going on around us and within us. When you become aware of thoughts, return ever-so-gently to the sacred word. ‘Thoughts’ is an umbrella term for every perception, including sense perceptions, feelings, images, memories, reflections and commentaries….he leads us by means of sacred experiences to the experience of emptiness. Anything that we perceive of God can only be a radiance of His presence and not God as He is Himself.”

I drive out of Cottonwood Canyon, anchored with the spiritual ballast of God’s Grace. I drive back into the wild winds of the desert.


America Magazine, “The Deep Mystery of God,” by Michael McCauley (October 18, 2004).

Intimacy with God: An Introduction to Centering Prayer by Thomas Keating

Finding Grace at the Center: The Beginning of Centering Prayer by M. Basil Pennington,

Tao Te Ching, translated by Stephen Mitchell. (I have a CD reading of this, which is very helpful when I have to drive into the traffic of Los Angeles).

About fatherbrad1971

Professor of Philosophy and World Religions at Saddleback Community College, Mission Viejo, CA. Episcopal priest since 1971 in Diocese of Los Angeles (retired). Owner of Desert Spirit Press, publishers of books on desert spirituality. Author, "The Spirit in the Desert: PIlgrimages to Sacred Sites in the Owens Valley." and "Encounters with the World's Religions: the Numinous on Highway 395". Memberships: Nevada Archaeological Association, Western Writers of America, California Cattlemen's Association, American Association of University Professors, Outdoor Writers of California, American Academy of Religion, Western Folklore Association.
This entry was posted in Blog and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply